A Senior’s Thoughts On a Drive-Thru Graduation
Finishing High School Should Not be Treated the Same as Getting a Coffee from a Starbucks Window
NOTE: Since the publishing of this column on Friday, May 15, LFHS has reinstated the backup dates of July 18 and August 1 in case health guidelines allow for an in-person ceremony (per announcement on May 19). If ultimately allowed in the future, this will be held in addition to the already-scheduled drive-thru commencement on June 6.
On May 13, caps and gowns were to be delivered to the doorsteps of this year’s graduating seniors. Upon receiving mine at my door, however, the thought of not being able to celebrate this achievement by walking across that stage was at the forefront of my mind. The Class of 2020 has had a rocky last semester that in no way is what you would want to sum up your years in school.
Yet somehow, with privileges and senior rights of passages being taken away left and right, it seems the news only got worse. LFHS Principal Dr. Chala Holland sent out an update regarding the class of 2020’s graduation ceremony and the further I got into the letter, the more my heart sunk. With this new plan, will I be able to physically walk across a stage? Yes. But will that represent anything other than a cheapened version of a ceremony so special and impactful in every Scout’s life? Unfortunately, not at all.
Many senior rights of passage were ones I was able to cope with giving up through justification of safety. While I looked forward to running around the streets of Lake Forest and Lake Bluff with a nerf gun in hand, being clapped out, having first dibs on the food trucks on e-day, going to a Cubs game on ditch day, and coming up with a class prank — not partaking in those activities means that things will go back to normal sooner, and those we love will remain safe.
The possibility of graduation not happening, however, never wavered in my mind until Wednesday. Being able to walk across a stage in front of the building that has shaped me into who I am and the people that got me here is the one thing that I will not sacrifice, even in the face of this pandemic.
LFHS had three backup dates booked for graduation; one in June, one in July, and one in August. Knowing that information, even in the face of this pandemic I had no doubt that I would eventually be able to receive my diploma in front of my peers and loved ones that got me to where I am.
Originally, communications with the LFHS community about their process explained their original philosophy behind the creation of many virtual substitutes. LFHS was prioritizing that those events actually would be honored and held in some form rather than extended out with backup dates that may ultimately all fall through, leaving us with nothing as it would be too late — a perfectly respectable viewpoint for most events. Graduation, however, was always deemed the exception due to how special and important it is.
Even with a virtual substitute on June 6 put in place in the May 4 announcement to compensate for possible later cancellations or students leaving early, the backup dates remained hanging in the future as reasonable hope for a traditional ceremony to be held as well.
This language changed in the recent announcement on Wednesday. Graduation will now take place on June 6th as a drive-thru and virtual ceremony.
While the language of the update makes it pretty evident that the backup dates are gone, there still hasn’t been full clarity as to whether those dates remain in the picture anymore. Senior Joey Goodsir sent an originally-accidental “reply all” to this update, asking that very question. Yet even now, the Class of 2020 was left with very hushed mention of the backup dates being cancelled.
As a senior of LFHS who’s time in high school came to a rapid halt one Thursday in March, I feel no need to rush to end my year even sooner. Had the school board waited until August to decide to hold a drive-thru graduation, I would still feel robbed, but I would be able to make sense of the situation. Had the virus not gotten any better by then, to hold a drive-thru or virtual graduation before college would, to me, make sense.
What does not make sense to me, however, is deciding to have this type of ceremony act as a replacement when there are three months of summer where travels and plans have been thrown out the window, and two more possible backup dates to hold this event. This sudden decision feels rushed, lazy, and not something we, as a class, deserve.
Through every uncertainty we, as a class, have faced throughout our life, to have this be representative of our youth is not what should be accepted. We entered the world in wake of 9/11, have spent our school careers becoming desensitized to the unfair reality or school shootings, and are leaving our youth behind within the wake of a global pandemic. We will never forget the memories we had in between those historical events, but the sentiment remains the same. We are incredibly strong, and to ‘cop-out’ this early is in no way representative of the Class of 2020’s moral strength and persistence.
Not only that, but a piece of paper is meaningless without the experience of what it represents. To be given a paper representative of a ceremony every Scout before and after us will have the chance to partake in, yet to not share that same experience, leaves the piece of paper feeling representative of just that: a piece of paper.
I, for one, would be content waiting until Thanksgiving break to walk across that stage with chairs still 6 feet apart and a line circling the front lawn if I had to, but that is besides the point. Calling it this early is not in Scout nature. That is the issue here. We, as Scouts, do not give up. We do not call it quits early, and we stand up for what we believe in. We do not back down unless it is the best and only option we are left with, and a drive-thru in June is simply not that.
I remember the fear and anxiety I felt walking out of the RMA and through the front hall being clapped in by my fellow Scouts. To not be clapped out during our last moment in blue and gold, is the one sacrifice I will not make.
Though I do not know the thoughts that went through the school boards’ minds when making this decision, and I trust they considered many options, this feels like calling a quits without getting a chance, and as seniors, we feel left behind.
As with any ceremony it is impossible to make the date work for every person involved or being honored. But with this decision disappointing seniors school-wide, the incentive to attend became drastically lower. Personally, driving up to the school on my own to receive a piece of paper does not seem enticing in the slightest. Attendance for this ceremony, and any ceremony here after, is uncertain. That should not be a driving force in the decision made to drastically move up this event.
If anything, having moments and events to look forward to right now is what is getting many of us through. Why cut off hope when there is no reason to? We need hope right now. We need reasons to stay home so we can go out later. We need incentives and motivations. Let graduation be that for us. Let seniors walk across a stage, let their loved ones cheer, let air horns blow and the choir sing, let them have their glory in blue and gold in front of the ivy. Do not call something this soon. Let it wait. If the circumstances require a drive-thru graduation in August, then so be it. But do not call this with possible dates as far into the future as the length of this shelter in place has been.
As a class, all we can ask now is for the backup dates for an in person ceremony with our loved ones in July and August to remain planned.
While a 16th birthday, drivers license, and 18th birthday are milestones in their own, a defining moment in someone’s youth is the great accomplishment of graduating High School. Regardless of their plans after that moment, it marks the end of a chapter and the beginning of a whole new way of life. To have a new beginning start like this, is simply not acceptable for me, and is nowhere close to what my peers and friends deserve.
SCO
Your donation will support the student journalists of Lake Forest High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
LFHS Senior Caroline Zeeman is heavily involved in her school community. She is active in New Media as both a student and a TA, works as president of Student...
LFHS Student • May 16, 2020 at 5:54 pm
Way to be a party-pooper, Pritzker
Isabelle • May 16, 2020 at 12:00 am
Well written Caroline. I completely agree- even if there are people unable to make the rescheduled graduation dates the class of 2020 deserves to be heard and have an opportunity for normalcy. The school should not back out of an in person graduation which they have had students hoping for.
kathryn hardy • May 15, 2020 at 11:05 pm
Love this article so, so much. It is so well written and speaks for a lot of us. I really, really hope the administration will take this to heart and keep the idea of an actual, traditional graduation in July or August. Drive thru graduation does NOT do our grade justice and we do not deserve that at all. I’ve had a great four years at LFHS and want to end it that way, and I know a drive thru graduation would be just the opposite. I may not be able to make the dates because of travel, but nothing compares to high school graduation. And for the plans I previously made before the virus, I will gladly cancel for a chance to have a real, traditional, walk on the stage, shake hands, receive my diploma, get clapped out, say goodbyes to my friends and teachers and counselors, and cherish the last moments of high school at a LFHS graduation.
Grace K • May 15, 2020 at 7:07 pm
I 100% agree with Kendra; the ceremony on June 6th should still be treated with respect and as an opportunity to come together as a FULL class. I also agree that keeping these backup dates as a hope is important, just in case :). I hope that we as a class can come together and make both happen; the class of 2020 leaves no one behind, and also does not give up hope. That has been our way, and will certainly not change now :).
Very well-written!!
Julie Barber • May 15, 2020 at 5:51 pm
I definitely agree with all of you above! We should treat this graduation as an actual graduation while also having the backup dates just in case. Very well said and written 🙂
Kendra Joachim • May 15, 2020 at 5:16 pm
Hello Caroline!
Thank you for writing this article. I do agree that this is not necessarily how we deserve to leave Lake Forest High School; however, for some people, it is our only option. I personally am going to the Air Force Academy, and my basic training starts on June 25th. For this reason, I won’t be able to attend either of the two postponed dates. I was actually really excited to hear about the drive-thru graduation because this is my only chance to get a sliver of similarity to how it usually is. I understand that I am one person, but there are other seniors in a situation similar to my own where there are no backup dates for us. I think that it is important to keep the backup dates, but I also think it is important that we as a class treat this drive-thru graduation on June 6th as if it is our only graduation because for some people it is. I personally made the choice to attend a school where these dates are not possible for me, but other kids don’t choose their reasons for not being in Lake Forest in July or August. When I first told my mom about the backup dates, she asked me “what about kids that are moving right after the school year?” My mom moved from New Jersey to Illinois right after she graduated, and she said that she wouldn’t have been able to get back to her school for a later graduation date. It is not necessarily easy to get back to Lake Forest, especially when the other two dates would still be up in the air. I will once again say that I do not want to get rid of the backup dates for graduation, but I think that this drive-thru graduation is a lot more meaningful to a lot of people than you are making it sound. I know that I am just one senior, and I know only a handful of kids are in a similar situation to me, but it is hard to hear what people are saying about a drive-thru graduation. We have definetly had our struggles as a class but even in hard times, one thing we never did was leave people in our class behind, and I would be lying if I said that I did not feel a little left behind after reading this article. So all I am asking of you and others that are reading this article is this: as a person with no other option but this drive-thru graduation, please treat this form of graduation better. I do fully support having back up dates, but everything is still so uncertain that those back up dates might not end up working either. This still could very well be everyone’s only graduation and having this form of graduation in August won’t work for a lot of people. We, The Class of 2020, are very strong and we do deserve better, but some of us can’t have that “better.” Keep the back up dates, keep the hope, but don’t treat a drive-thru graduation as something bad.
Thank you for your time,
Kendra Joachim
Catherine Greub • May 15, 2020 at 4:56 pm
Caroline— I don’t think anyone could’ve said it in any better way! Absolutely amazing! We Scouts deserve to have these back up days and something a little extra special since everything was taken away from us so soon. I 100% support you!