She Speaks for All of Us
You Shall Not Crucify Humankind upon a Cross of Greed
In Washington the storm of impeachment is strengthening. In London the boisterous thunderhead of Brexit is looming. And in New York’s City the world’s leaders are gathering to discuss the steadily-warming climate behind the rising seas and burning forests and expanding deserts and dying reefs.
They were addressed on Monday by Greta Thunberg, our generation’s bravest and most passionate advocate for a global response to climate change. Her voice dripped with emotion and it seemed that her eyes were not far behind. She lamented what our forebears have done to our planet even as she called for change.
That change came from the most unlikely of places — President Donald Trump. The president of the United States of America, a 73-year-old man who escaped the Vietnam War by the good graces of “bone spurs,” made fun of a 16-year-old girl who overcame Asperger’s and sailed across the Atlantic Ocean to speak before the leaders of the world.
She seems like a very happy young girl looking forward to a bright and wonderful future. So nice to see! https://t.co/1tQG6QcVKO
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 24, 2019
In his infantile tweet Trump elevated the standard operating procedure of politics — divert from the matter at hand — many, many notches. He listened to Greta’s words, which were more eloquent and passionate by far than anything he has uttered to date, only to turn them around entirely in the most demeaning way possible. She is not a “very happy young girl.” She is an activist in the mold of Mohandas Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr, notably spearheading last week’s nonviolent climate strike that drew four million protesters.
But the president has never been particularly good at facts, logic, or respect for other human beings; he leeches off the genuine pain of others for his own personal gain. So it is no real surprise that he ignored Monday’s UNDP report projecting a full three degrees of warming by the end of the century — twice the threshold set by the 2015 Paris Agreement — in favor of picking on a teenager like a neighborhood bully. Rather, it is damning evidence for the failure of the American Dream; instead of building a better future for posterity, President Trump and other leaders alternate between mocking and ignoring us.
On their watch the dream of a better tomorrow has faded across the board. Democracy is retreating across the globe. War without end ravages the Middle East. The fisheries are collapsing, the forests are vanishing. 90 percent of large fish stocks have been stolen from the sea, less than half of the jungles remain. Iran and Saudi Arabia beat the drums of war. Freedom House has chronicled 12 consecutive years of declining global freedom — including in the United States. Things fall apart, the center cannot hold; mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.
Yet this is no prelude to the Second Coming. No one is coming to dig us out of the hole humanity has dug; we’re all stuck on this planet together.
It is a beautiful world, this Earth of ours. I have hiked the trails of Glacier National Park and the arid Southwest, traversed the trackless lakes and portages of the Boundary Waters, witnessed the rosy sunset on the Tetons and the ruddy dawn on the Sangre de Cristos, been blinded by the brilliant glaciers of Greenland, fished Alaska’s icy streams and lakes, laid eyes on New Zealand’s foggy fjords. I have been egregiously lucky, treated to miracles for no greatness of my own.
Yet there is so much more to see! The roaring might of the Colorado crashing down through the rainbow-painted walls of the Grand Canyon, the sunless splendor of the uttermost oceanic abyss, the iceclad Himalyan roof of the world, the searing sands of the Sahara, the shadowed eaves of the Amazon — Earth, whose very name means “dirt,” is more beautiful than any Starry Night, more musical than any Ode to Joy, and more magical than any Harry Potter.
But you, O venerable ancestors whose wisdom we must honor and whose bills we must one day pay, you are destroying all of it. The Great Barrier Reef is best described as dead. Southern California is even less fit for human habitation than it was initially. The Amazon is still aflame. Entire countries will be underwater before the end of the century.
How dare you! How dare you rape the mother of us all and talk of “family values”! How dare you defile and destroy that which belongs neither to you nor to us nor to our children nor to our children’s children but to all humankind! How dare you give in like gluttonous pigs to your every base desire and accuse our spokesperson of being childish and overly emotional! How dare you!
Greta speaks for all of us. Her every word and turn of phrase rings true in our hearts like a billion resounding bells, save one — “we will never forgive you.” There I disagree; I say that we shall. If we somehow survive this mess we will forgive you for it all. We all obey the Christ you say you worship, we all follow the Allah you say is great, we all tread the Eightfold Path you say you walk. We do not judge; though oppressed, denied, abandoned, we will bear it all. “I repent” and “sorry” only ever helped the truly regretful anyway.
But if you find the will to right the wrongs you’ve wrought to make us better off — odd, how much that reads like the American Dream — then we have this to say:
We the children of the planet Earth believe that this species should commit itself to achieving the goal, before the next decade is out, of reducing emissions to zero and creating a free and fair society for all human beings — everywhere in the world.
She speaks for all of us. You would do well to listen.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Lake Forest High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Casey Murray is a senior at Lake Forest High School, where he participates in many endeavors, such as Model UN and Latin Club. He enjoys meteor showers,...
Deb Schneider • Nov 8, 2019 at 7:37 am
Casey, well said! Thank you for sharing your opinion!
A fellow student news adviser • Nov 1, 2019 at 1:34 pm
SNO brought us here…Is there any chance we can reprint this (your article) verbatim, on our student news website? It’s extremely well written and a starting point for many good conversations that need to be had. Rather than try to copy your work, or merely link to it, we’d like to run it like a syndicated article. Please let us know as soon as possible.
Thanks for being passionate and for taking the time to consider our request.
Mr. Z. Anderson
Philadelphia, NY
Brian Runft • Oct 4, 2019 at 9:29 am
Great article Casey! Well done.
lori redding • Oct 3, 2019 at 3:36 pm
Kudos Casey for shining a light on a bright young female global activist. Why do some people feel threatened to learn that today’s youth actually have funds of first hand knowledge! Paid or not paid, a refreshing, yet, soft punch, to the power differential in D.C.
Sarah Mack • Sep 29, 2019 at 10:17 pm
Good article! Even though there are a lot of different stances that people could take on this, you were really honest about how you felt about the issue, and I really admire that!
Will Elliott • Sep 28, 2019 at 5:09 pm
Amazing work, as usual, Casey! Thank you for your tasteful writing and having the dignity to attach your name to what you believe in.
Willow Volkert • Sep 27, 2019 at 7:50 pm
Great job Casey!! I love this article!!
Greta Thunberg Skeptic • Sep 27, 2019 at 5:19 pm
“With the painfully disgusting feeling that I am getting from some of these comments put aside””, “”Every word that you said was not one to be argued with.” – Supporter of Saving the World (and our future): This is the exact problem I was referencing in my previous comment. The arrogance coming from certain people regarding this topic is very much disenfranchising people. If you really wanted to save the planet and not just earn social brownie points, you would not be so polarizing in your characterization of the debate. Can I not have an opinion?
Katie Pierce • Sep 27, 2019 at 3:23 pm
Bravo once again, Casey!
Kelsey Marx • Sep 27, 2019 at 3:20 pm
Right on point as always, Casey. Thanks for capturing in such eloquence the raw frustration that’s been evoked in so many of us.
Natalie Logue • Sep 27, 2019 at 1:51 pm
Amazing article Casey! Thank you for bringing attention to this pressing issue and thank you for sharing such passionate views
Supporter of Saving the World (and our future) • Sep 27, 2019 at 1:36 pm
With the painfully disgusting feeling that I am getting from some of these comments put aside, I want to applaud your writing, Casey. I think it is such a brave thing to speak your personal opinion out to a community with such divided beliefs; I wish that it was easier to speak up in this world. Every word that you said was not one to be argued with. This article has such power to stir up conversation in this school and I think that is something that is very much needed. Thank you for bringing up a topic that some of us are too scared to speak up about. Climate change is very much present and everyone needs to put in the effort for the sake of our lives and the sake of the planet. I hope that this article hits other students in this community as much as it hit me.
Martha Clifford • Sep 27, 2019 at 12:52 pm
Incredibly well said article, Casey! Thank you for bringing this important issue to light!
Ryan Peters • Sep 27, 2019 at 8:22 am
Well done, Casey. I commend you for passionately standing behind what you believe in!
Jim Mergl • Sep 27, 2019 at 8:07 am
Well said Casey! It’s miserable that anyone would mock a passionate youth for standing up for what she believes. Thank you for calling this out for what out is.
Greta Thunberg Skeptic • Sep 27, 2019 at 7:47 am
I can say at the very least that Greta Thunberg does not speak for myself. By supporting Greta Thunberg, more specifically her militant style and aggressive tone, you are turning off millions of political moderates across the world. Her broader message is hardly a radical or militant one. The way she goes about advocating those policies and viewpoints is quite harsh though. Getting up and telling the United Nations General Assembly that “you ruined my childhood” is quite ridiculous. Additionally, this article is hardly non-partisan. Yes I am aware op-eds are not supposed to be non-partisan. Let me be clear, I do not support President Trump. Yet despite my position I take great issue with the little digs peppered throughout the article. Come on, is talking about his potential draft dodging relevant to the conversation at all? That is not very professional. If the climate movement is so important, why is a 16 year old with hardly any life experience leading it? I really do not want to criticize Greta Thunberg, after all, she is a child being forced into this. Her hippie parents are shoving this rhetoric down her throat and have brainwashed her. Just look into her personal history. At one point she stopped eating because she was so upset about climate change. That is not healthy for a child of that age to be worrying so much about something she has little control over as a child. Now of course the big argument here is that even a child can change the world. I really do not think Greta Thunberg has changed people’s minds over to her movement. If anything she has moved people to the other side. Let me be clear, we should not be criticizing Greta specifically. I feel very bad for her. Her parents and the people who support her are throwing a 16 year old to the wolves by putting her in such a spotlight, and thus are the ones we should critique.